QUOTE (wagdoll @ Mar 27 2008, 05:25 PM)

Yesterday, I described the RBN thing as like they are the centre of a huge spiderweb, they sit at the middle, people come to them for exploit packages that they sell, then each part of the spiderweb goes out and spreads this stuff over the internet. The connections that we've seen 'suggest' strongly that this hacker is connected to that spiderweb, even if it is somewhere low down and he's not "one of them" per se. If Sini has other information that can't be refuted as not everyone knows what that information is. Is it entirely impossible that it does gel somewhere? Sini has information "we" don't have if we have never been affected by having him in our servers, but those connections still exist. Either they're a coincidence or a red herring or something else?
I don't think it's exactly the same as cheat bots, because malware affects all of us. You have special PO areas where you can put info on cheat bots, but we don't have the same thing for members everywhere? If you hide the domains they are using for drive by hijacks how can anyone protect themselves from the hijack if you sweep it under the carpet? In security forums they share information on how hackers gain access to servers, not so that hackers can get better access, but so that more people can protect their servers, and more visitors to the sites can be protected. Very few people are going to be inclined to join one of these hacker groups and try it for themselves, if they wanted to I used to have some links to open sites where you could pick up the same exploit code as was found in things like stelaartois - it's openly available, but you need a little expertise even as a script kiddy to be able to understand and use it. I know it's there but I couldn't use it, because I recognise it like I can recognise French language, but I can't converse in the language. I wouldn't direct link to those sites publically though, but I would link to something that explained how a server had been compromised or a domain that was being used for drive bys. If Sini has information she feels is best shared off the forums then that's her call though and I'm not disagreeing with that or criticising her for it. She knows what she has and I don't so I can't say I wouldn't do the same thing in her position. If Sini has proof that all of the connections are coincidences or don't exist, it would be helpful to understand why but that's not going to happen so she's going to have to accept that other people have seen something that looked very convincing and it's going to be hard for them to understand that without access to the info she has (if that makes any sense, and I'm not saying that's a reason for her to share what she knows in public.)
I agree about limiting information spread by only posting it in one place, but there are rules in place at this forum that prevent information being posted in this forum if the information is in another place. There is a rule that stops you linking to the info in that place, I don't think it would be right to just copy other peoples posts and not say properly where it came from, so you can't bring the information or warnings here very easily to share it or for people here to discuss it here. People aren't all simply choosing to only post in one place, they can't bring the information here due to the rules.
QUOTE (wagdoll @ Mar 27 2008, 05:37 PM)

I don't agree, sorry. You're discussing an issue with people from GPF, where else they post is irrelevant. None of the posts I read were saying anything like that about WIW.
From what I can see you are both trying to help people and sometimes have a different way of doing that. Everyone can't agree on everything all the time, even when they both have the same aims.
Anyway I am sorry for posting in here, like you say it's none of my business and I wish people would keep it out of my way but when they bring it to my computer I start thinking it is my business. All I was trying to do was post something I thought might be of help to someone to understand it. I was wrong, I shouldn't have tried. Sophie says it's our choice, but I wonder if it's worth it if we are all think labeling people as one side or the other is the most important thing.
Hi Wag,
About what can or cannot be said, I do trust Sini if she thinks that for the time being it is better to not post everything otherwhise she would post the information. From what I can read, the people who need the info will receive it from Sini so it's not as if it is such a big secret, it is just not posted openly. Personally I see Sini being very committed on this and I really do hope that it will all work out.
About posting in order to have the biggest audience possible, besides this one, there are other fora and not here, not there is the info posted regularly by some but on one forum, so the audience will remain limited anyway.
As for GPF, the forum where some post about bad stuff was already banned from here before those sections about nasties/malaware etc .. were started so when it was decided to post it there, everyone knew it would not be linked here back then already.
I must admit I don't care for the other forum, I used to think I should fight to show the real colour of it but I have given that up by now, one thing is sure, I and others have probably been more harmed and hurt by it than by all the malawares and hackings we have been the victim of .. some things you can't just hide and fake they never existed or restore with a back up or fix by having a new computer.
This being said, I do appreciate people helping here regardless where else they post, it is not because I don't support one forum that I judge and blame everyone who posts there, we all have our own experiences and opinions, as long as we remain civil and tolerant, we should be able to live with those differences.
From what I could see, people appreciated your help and explanations in this thread so there is not one single reason to regret having posted, on the contrary.
Sophie